The shooting happened in June on West End Avenue, just off Wedington Drive.
According to investigators, a fight broke out between two groups of men outside the apartments.
Officers said Martez Butler opened fire, narrowly missing some of the other people inside the apartment.
One day after the shooting, police arrested Butler, Aaron Walton, Derrick Doolittle and Cassie Watkins.
For the past several months, Fayetteville investigators have been looking for the fifth person they believe was involved in the crime, 21-year-old Keon Plummer.
Plummer was booked into the Washington County Detention Center Friday and charged with attempted murder, committing a terroristic act and aggravated assault.