According to the Sheriff's office, the Hartford Assembly of God was broken into in June, but the report was only filed recently.
The investigation determined 18-year-old Justin Wilkerson and 18-year-old Dakota Ham broke a window to the church, entered the building and took a bass guitar valued at $400.
The bass guitar was located at a pawn shop in the Mansfield area and has since been recovered.
Wilkerson and Ham were charged with commercial burglary, a class C felony, which carries a punishment of up to 10 years in prison.
The Sebastian County Sheriff's Office was assisted by the Hartford Police Department in this investigation.